via Austin Kleon
Marginalia
Maybe changing attention spans are leading to new ways of listening but there are always going to be interesting artists who are able to see opportunities within that.
I sort of feel like, âWell, 10 million autotune fans canât be wrong. Let me see if I can understand whatâs happening here, what the aesthetics are.â And if I spend enough time on it, I generally find some musical value
The fundamentals of musical storytelling are always going to be there: tension and release, fantasy and reality, sparseness versus denseness. These are the things that music has always been about, whichever culture or era youâre in. Theyâre still there. Everything gets flattened or compressed more, but that was already happening from the romantic era to the impressionist era
If you can steal without getting caught, then youâve pulled off the perfect crime â which is what an artist is supposed to do. Youâre not meant to come up with new things as an artist; no artist would say thatâs what they do. Itâs all about taking your influences and hopefully filtering them through a personal viewpoint
Iâm all about letting the listener decide who fucked up and who was able to steal with finesse, you know? I mean maybe itâs different if youâre a struggling musician working your crappy day-job and you feel like some giant artist is profiting off something you did; I can imagine thereâs a lot of emotional frustration there
My Month of October
I remember a few years ago participating in ATC21s project exploring collaborative problem solving. They defined it as follows:
I think that the project I am currently engaged with is the first time I personally have truly engaged within a project involving so many moving parts that no matter how skilled you are it would not be possible to be over every aspect. This was brought to the fore this month when one of the pieces associated with development was temporarily offline. No matter what I did, all I could do was wait. I think that this is the real 21st century, one of complexity, communication and moving parts.
On the family front, my wife and I took our two girls to see Small Foot at Village Junior. In the days of digital downloads and dwindling numbers, it was a reminder that sometimes the opportunity is to be different. With various activities for children beforehand, a built in intermission and lower seating, it was a great experience. The film was also interesting. A fun loving deep philosophical romp. We were all winners.
Personally, I have been participating in the 9x9x25 challenge. What I have enjoyed most is finding new voices to converse with. I have also started reading Zeynep Tufekciâs Twitter and Tear Gas as a part of Bryan Alexanderâs next book club. New music that has grabbed me this month has been St.Vincentâs reworking of Masseduction, the soundtrack for A Star is Born, Honey by Robyn and Kimbraâs reimagining of Primal Heart.
In regards to my writing, here was my month in posts:
Reflections on Fijian Education: Using the Modern Learning Canvas as a lens, here are some of my observations on the resources, policies and purpose of school in Fiji.
Digital Mindfulness, Can It Exist?: Building on my thoughts of âbeing analogueâ, I unpack what it might mean to be âdigitally mindfulâ and does such a thing exist?
Would the World Be Better without Mobile Devices?: This is a response to my reading of James Bridleâs book The New Dark Age and the place of the smartphones in the future.
In addition to all this, here then are some of the thoughts that have also left me thinking:
Learning and Teaching
Flip the System Australia: Jon Andrews discusses the work of some of the school leaders pushing back on the accountability agenda to respond to the questions and concersn of their own contexts. Along with posts from Deborah Netolicky and Cameron Paterson, the editors of Flip the System Australia provide an overview of the various pieces included in the book designed to provide an alternative voices within the educational debate. An interview from the ACEL Conference was also featured on the TER Podcast.
Getting personal: conferring with learners as they inquire: Kath Murdoch discusses the importance of conferring during the inquiry process. These conversations can contribute to formative assessment, getting to know students building trust, providing feedback and learning about learning. To support all this, Murdoch provides a list of tips and questions, such as providing multiple ideas if suggesting solutions or articulating what the child has taught you. I have found one of the biggest challenges with conferencing is to support students in owning this. In a different post, Tom Whitby discusses the power associated with communicating and conferring with parents and explains how this can influence our knowledge of students and the way they learn.
Video in Situ: John Stewart reflects on the way in which the La Blogothèque website / YouTube channel redefines the video experience, creating new and unique possibilities. He wonders if the same changes could be incorporated into the filming of educational videos for blended and online courses, in particular, the possibilities for capturing field work. I have written about the Take Away Shows before, discussing the possibility of redefining the whole pedagogical experience. The reference to capturing field work reminds me of an early Google Glass exercise capturing CERN.
VFX Artist Reveals the True Scale of the Universe: The team at Corridor Crew, how big the universe would be if the Earth were shrunk down to the size of a tennis ball. There are sometimes questions about the limits of the next best thing to being there. However, this video visualises something that you would be unable to imagine otherwise. Another resource associated with the universe is Alice Leungâs use of Ozobots to represent the eclipse and the nitrogen cycle.
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCTuirkcRwo?version=3&rel=1&fs=1&autohide=2&showsearch=0&showinfo=1&iv_load_policy=1&wmode=transparent&w=840&h=473%5D
Edtech
Silicon Valleyâs Saudi Arabia Problem: Anand Giridharadas explores Saudi Arabiaâs growing involvement with Silicon Valley. Through their investment in SoftBank, they have invested in a long list of startups including Wag, DoorDash, WeWork, Plenty, Cruise, Katerra, Nvidia and Slack. The question is at what cost? Silence? Support? With the recent disappearance of a Saudi Journalist, Jamal Khashoggi, these are compromises that need to be considered. Listen to the recent episode of the Have You Heard podcast for more on Anand Giridharadasâ work. Also read the work of Audrey Watters and Benjamin Doxtdator for more discussion on investment in Silicon Valley (and subsequently EdTech).
My URL Is: Eddie Hinkle has started a new fortnightly podcast interviewing different people within the IndieWeb community about their websites. Although the conversations can become rather technical, they do provide an insight into why people make some of the choices that they do. So far Hinkle has interviewed Aaron Parecki and Rosemary Orchard. In some ways this is similar to Uses This, a site dedicated to the workflows people use, David Hopkinsâ curated book #EdTechRations and Alan Levineâs #WhyDomains project.
Stupid Qubit â Quantum Computing for the Clueless/001: Jim Mortleman and Stuart Houghton begin their exploration of quantum computing. This is humorous look at such a dry and difficult concept. Along with the Crash Course Computer Science series</a>, these resources provide a different perspective to technology. Mortleman and Houghton are also open to questions.
Android: a 10-year visual history: The team at Verge look back on 10 years of the Android operating system. With a focus on the stock open sourced code it is interesting to consider what has been developed outside of this. It is also interesting to compare this with Mozillaâs efforts to enter the mobile market with Firefox OS.
Friction-Free Racism: Chris Gilliard unpacks the inherent racism encoded into the operations of the surveillance state. See for example Spotifyâs recent announcement to add genealogy data to their algorithm. As a part of this investigation, Gilliard provides a number of questions to consider when thinking about such data.
Storytelling and Reflection
The Comforting Fictions of Dementia Care: This lengthy read provides an interesting insight into the life and times of those with dementia. It reflects on the changes in care, with the move away from drugs and creating the conditions to support memory. Associated with this is the problem of lying and memory. It is interesting to consider this alongside Clive Thompsonâs book Smarter Than You Think, especially in regards to his discussion of memory and technology. This also reminds me of the episode âSan Juniperoâ from Season Three of Black Mirror.
Chilly Gonzales breaks down the essence of music: Whether it be his version of Daft Punkâs Too Long or contribution to Jamie Lidellâs work, I have always been fascinated with the work of Chilly Gonzales, long before I even knew who Chilly Gonzales was. This article from Cian Traynor provides an insight into the thoughts and actions behind the bravado. If you have not experienced the âgeniusâ before, I highly recommend his masterclasses, especially his breakdown of Taylor Swiftâs Shake It Off. Another interesting look at the history of music was provided by Voxâs look at the influence of the Fairlight CMI.
Warm Data (Team Human): In a discussion with Douglas Rushkoff, Nora Bateson discusses the concept of âWarm Dataâ and the interconnected nature of everything. For Bateson, it is the relationships which bring the data alive. This all stems from the notion of âwarm ideasâ, as idea that leads you into another idea of relations. In this circumstance it is about going beyond departments and instead focusing on context. I was left wondering where this might fit with Pasi Salsbergâs push for âsmall dataâ in education.
12 Modes of Failure: Julian Stodd attempts to identify different reasons failure may occur. This is list is a useful provocation when thinking about where something may have gone wrong and what the next iteration may be. On the flipside, Stodd wrote a second post exploring 12 modes of innovation. This is what Eric Ries would describe as opportunities to pivot and change.
In light of the release of Bruno Latourâs book Down to Earth in English, Ava Kofman unpacks some of the legacies of his ideas and the impact that they have had on science today. I was initially introduced to Latour and Actor-Network Theory (ANT) through Ian Guest. Bruno Latour, the Post-Truth Philosopher, Mounts a Defense of Science â Along with the concept of assemblages and rhizomatic learning, Latourâs work interests me in regards to better appreciating the connected nature of things.
FOCUS ON ⌠Twitter
I have been thinking quite a bit about Twitter lately, however I have been unable to properly clarify my concerns. Having started a post a number of weeks ago, I cannot work out what my concerns are. I therefore decided in the interim to collect together all my pieces in one spot.
Guides
Overviews
The Ultimate Guide to Twitter: As the name suggests, this guide written by Sue Waters and Kathleen Morris covers just about everything that you need to know from a technical perspective. I attempted such a guide before, but obviously missed a few features.
Twitter EDU: David Trussâ one-stop-all-you-need-to-know-guide to Twitter.
Taming Twitter for Time-strapped Teachers and Techies: Eric Curts guide to getting going with Twitter.
The Complete Guide to Twitter Lingo: A complete glossary of terms you may come across in tweets.
The Other Chat on Twitter: A discussion of asynchronous slow-chats as an alternative to the usual Twitter chats.
Meeting People is Easy â on Connecting to People on Twitter: Some of the strategies that I have used to broaden my network, such as lists and chats.
Paper Twitter: Why and How to Teach Digital Technologies with Paper: Royan Lee discusses the use of paper tweets to provide a safe and simple entry point for learners when it comes to digital technologies.
EduTwitter
Is there value in tweeting?: Aviva summarises some of the benefits associated with sharing student learning online.
Twitter In My Classroom: Bec Spink share some ways that she use(d) Twitter in her classroom.
The #TweetingAztecs Project: Jacques du Toit discusses his project involving students creating accounts for historical figures and role-playing their various interactions on Twitter.
Professional Development: Got a Twitter Minute?: Silvia Rosenthal Tolisano shares a number of one minutes reflections to support teacher professional development.
Add-ons
TAGS Explorer: Martin Hawkseyâs Twitter visualisation tool.
Keeping your Twitter Archive fresh and freely hosted on Github Pages: Martin Hawkseyâs guide to keeping your downloaded Twitter archive fresh on Github Pages using Google Apps Script.
Build an instant Twitter dashboard, with just a little code: Kris Shaffer discusses tweetmineR, a suite of tools to collect, analyze, and visualize large quantities of tweets.
Unfollowing Everybody: Anil Dash discusses the steps he took to unfollow everyone on Twitter and start again. There are some interesting ideas in this piece, such as archiving a list of people you are following.
Reflections
General
A Personal Twitter Tour: Riffing on Ian Guestâs post unpacking how he uses Twitter, here are some of the ways I use(d) the platform. As a note, here are some of these habits have since changed.
Can You Really Find Wisdom in One-line?: A response to Peter Skillenâs concern about âone-line wisdomâ.
Marginal Notes: Ian Guestâs blog documenting his research into professional develop in 140 characters.
Tower of Song: Bonnie Stewart suggest that Twitter both situates users within the realm of networked scholarship, as well as enhances their sense of community and engagement in their work in general.
What Twitter offers teachers: The evidence: Kathryn Holmes reflects on research demonstrating some of the benefits of online collaboration and communication, such as a means of connecting with like-minded teachers and control over professional learning.
The four types of online discussion. Where are you?: Ian OâByrne explores the four ways people generally respond when they engage online, including deliberate, dialogue, declare and debate.
Twitterâs Past, Present and FutureâââLess Public Square, More Private Rooms: Preston Towers discusses Twitter and what it represents to wider society.
Technical Twitter
Twitter Should Eliminate the Retweet: Taylor Lorenz discusses the retweet functionality in Twitter and what it might mean to get rid of it. A number of add-ons and extensions are shared for modifying your timeline.
âJust an Ass-Backward Tech Companyâ: How Twitter Lost the Internet War: Maya Kosoff looks at Twitterâs attwmpts to combat spam and abuse. One of the problem is that Twitter has never set clear guidelines for what kind of language or behavior will get somebody banned. Another challenge has been the infrastructure the platform was built on.
Twitter is being unbundled before our eyes: Casey Newton looks at how Amazon and Reddit are breaking off various business lines from Twitter.
Spot a Bot: Identifying Automation and Disinformation on Social Media: Bill Fitzgerald and Kris Shaffer explore the world automated disinformation (see this report from Alex Hern for an example.) They unpack the different traits assocaited with bots and how Twitter could fix this problem.
Living In A Post Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram API World: Kin Lane discusses the current move to lock down social media APIs. He suggests that this could all have been avoided by having clearer guidelines in the beginning.
8 Important Things You Need to Know About Twitter Hashtags: Mark Barnes helps make sense of the hashtag on Twitter and how to use them.
Twitter Bio Generator: Use this tool to generate a Twitter bio for yourself.
Toxic Twitter
Justine Sacco, Internet Justice, And The Dangers Of A Righteous Mob: Tarun Wadhwa asks what would have happened if Joanne had in fact been hacked? Also makes the comparison with the Boston Bombing fiasco involving the use of social media.
Five Tips for Twitter: Graham Brown-Martin provides a guide to what appears to the arsenal of indignant eduTwitter attack dogs and avenging angels.
Arguing on Education Twitter: BINGO: In light of some of the sometimes unsavoury debate and derision that occurs on Twitter, Deb Netolicky collects together some of the insults and graceless disagreements in the form of a bingo board.
The 29 Stages Of A Twitterstorm In 2018: A fictious account of how the Twitter anger factory works.
The botnet cometh: Kris Shaffer shares his experience of the social media version of a Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) cyber-attack.
Should We Tweet?
Should Every Teacher in the World Really be on Twitter?: A collection of alternatives for cultivating connections online through aggregation, bookmarking and speaking with people.
Is Sharing Caring? â A Reflection on Comments and Social Media: An exploration of what it mean to be caring in online spaces and how this relates to sharing. This builds upon the risks of hospitality online.
Anyone Want To Have a Real Conversation?: Dean Shareski suggest that branding has taken a space like Twitter and turned it away from many of the casual and social interactions, to one where chats and platitudes dominate the stream.
Twitterâs Misleading User Experience When Reporting Abuse: Bill Fitzgerald explains that when Twitter automatically hides offensive content from the people who have reported it, they create the impression that they have done something, when they have done nothing.
Dear Twitter, Itâs Not, Itâs You: David Hopkins explains his waning interest in Twitter, raising concerns over the way it reflects âusâ and how other groups are using it.
An Act of Heresy: Chris Betcher discusses his concerns with Twitter chats, suggesting that it wrangles Twitter to be and do something that it was not necessarily designed for.
Why Do We Give a Tweet?: Robert Schuetz wonders if educators get âturned offâ Twitter by meformer behavior that can dominate the Twitter stream?
Is Twitter the Best Option for Online Professional Development?: Audrey Watters warns about becoming too dependent on Twitter as the solution to our professional development needs.
Why Iâm not using Twitter next month: Doug Belshaw argues that we need to replace our reliance on the likes of Facebook and Twitter before politicians think that direct digital democracy through these platforms would be a good idea.
READ WRITE RESPOND #034
So that is October for me, how about you? As always, interested to hear. Also, feel free to forward this on to others if you found anything of interest or maybe you want to subscribe? Otherwise, archives can be found here. Cover image via JustLego101.
Thank you for sharing the different covers. It is an intriguing collection.
Where jazz has its standards, it feels that the (post)modern standards are songs we have ingrained in our memory to a point where we apprehend every bend and squeal, even if it is not performed.
It is interesting to think of these songs in association with algorithms and the choice of what is played and performed. Has nostalgia replaced originality or is all music copied as people like Chilly Gonzales demonstrate.
Here I am again reminded of a comment from William Gibson:
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
A reflection on the music that represented my soundtrack for 2018.
Depth of Field (Sarah Blasko)
Although Blaskoâs use of synth bass and programmed beats with this album leads to comparisons with artists like Goldfrapp, Depth of Field never quite reaches the same dancefloor intensity. Instead the mix often creates a feeling of fragility. In listening I was reminded in part of LCD Soundsystemâs american dreams, as the more I listened, the more the choice to hold back on certain elements seemed to make more sense. Overall, I found it one of those albums that never seems settled and subsequently hooks you in because of it.
I would place this album between Goldfrapp and Lamb.
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m4QcP84uU-A?controls=0%5D
Lilac Everything (Emma Louise)
Lilac Everything is a captivating album. The decision of Emma Louise to definitively augment her voice makes for an intriguing listening experience. Where some may be critical of the artificial nature of pitch correction, the use in this circumstance is novel and critically challenges the notion of identity and belonging. There is just something uncanny about listening to a female artist taking on a male voice.
I would place this album between Father John Misty and Jeff Buckley.
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9J6K4VmZ7V4?rel=0%5D
Isaac Gracie (Isaac Gracie)
The strength of Isaac Gracieâs self titled album is the rawness of his voice. In a world of lush productions, this album cuts things back to basics. Many of the tracks consist of drums, bass and guitar. This simplicity allows Gracie to stand out. In some ways this reminds me of acts like Beach House and London Grammar, who fill out their sound with less rather than more.
I would place this album between Art of Fighting and London Grammar.
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnnKv9SyQgo?controls=0%5D
Wildness (Snow Patrol)
It is interesting listening to artists who I grew up with, but have not necessarily listened to lately. They change, the world changes, music changes, I changed. The one thing that remains the same with Snow Patrol is Gary Lightbodyâs distinctive voice. There is nuance with this album with a continual battle between acoustic and electric. Although some have argued that Jacknife Leeâs polished production is to the detriment of the album, I found that once I stopped comparing the album with the past it grew on me.
I would place this between Radiohead and Collective Soul
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUaVhMjlPZg?controls=0%5D
MassEducation (St. Vincent)
I loved last yearâs MassEduction, but the rawness of Annie Clarkâs voice accompanied by Thomas Bartlett on piano takes the music to a whole new level for me. Even though her music is relatively structured she manages to find creativity within constraint in this reworking. This is epitomised by a track like Slow Disco, which she has played supported by Bartlettâs piano, strings on the album, acoustically for NPR Tiny Desk and electroically in the Taylor Swift inspired reworking as Slow Fast Disco. Other artists to peel the layers back this year were Kimbra and Chilly Gonzales.
I would place this between MTV Unplugged and Chilly Gonzales
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdmSRfbjQlY?controls=0%5D
BONUS: Beckstrom Holiday Extravaganza Volume X (Chris Beckstrom)
Christmas is always an interesting time of year when it comes to music. There are those like Michael Buble that have carved out a niche. Last year Sia created an interesting album of original music. With all this said there is something truly joyful about Chris Beckstromâs âHoliday Extravaganzasâ, where each year he electronically reimagines a collection of Christmas classics. The pictures are also a useful reflection of the effort involved.
I would place this between Daft Punk and Aphex Twin
Beckstrom Holiday Extravaganza Volume X by Chris Beckstrom
Some of the artists that stood out for me this year, but did not make the cut include The Presets, Amy Shark, Guy Pearce, The Wombats, Nils Frahm, Missy Higgins, Dreams and Aphex Twin.
Looking back it feels like the year of imagining, whether it be different versions (St Vincent) or new ground (Emma Louise). So what about you? What music has caught your attention this year? What albums and artists have you had on high rotation? Is there something that seems to tie your year together? As always, comments welcome.
If you enjoy what you read here, feel free to sign up for my monthly newsletter to catch up on all things learning, edtech and storytelling.
Share this:
Email
Reddit
Twitter
Google
Pocket
Tumblr
LinkedIn
Like this:
Like Loading…
Music of 2018 in Review, or The Year of Musical Reimaginings by Aaron Davis is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Also on:
Switched on Pop is a music podcast featuring Nate Sloan and Charlie Harding. Like other podcasts, such as Chilly Gonzalezâ Music is Cool, Song Exploder and Holistic Songwriting, the podcast breaks down songs and looks at how they work. However, where it differs is that Sloan and Harding often provide a lot more interpretation on the interconnection between lyrics and music. Sometimes this is about word painting, but other times it is about interpreting meaning and connection with artists wider oeuvre.
via Triple J
I have long been encapsulated by Chilly Gonzales and his âmusical geniusâ. Whether it be his work with various artists, pop music masterclasses and minor christmas album, I have been enamoured with the way in which he manages to break music down to capture what is essential. I was therefore intrigued by a book on Enya.
I purchased the Enya: A Treatise on Unguilty Pleasures in good faith with little idea what to expect. I thought it might be some sort of technical breakdown of Enyaâs work. Although I am always interested in what Chilly Gonzales has to say about any sort of music, I was not sure how interesting an extended breakdown of Enyaâs music would actually be. What I had not expected was the way in which Gozanales used Enya and her music as a frame for his own memoir on music.
Fine Gonzalas spoke about the Enyaâs lullaby quality, the guilt often associated with liking such music, her use of the pizzicato strings on the Roland D-50 synthesiser in lieu of a rhythm track and the way in which she has managed her career by continually say no. However, often these references are merely jumping off points for Gonzales to reflect upon his own memories and experiences with music. Whether it be the relationship between harmony and melody:
His desire for music that can be both serious and drop into the background:
Disdain for loud voices:
And his preference for the music over lyrics:
In some ways Gonzalesâ reflection on Enya reminds me of Damian Cowellâs Only the Shit You Love podcast. Like Gonzalasâ constraint as a guide, Cowell uses his video series as a starting point from which to reflect upon music past and present. They are both musical memoirs of artists engaging in artifice. Maybe the real purpose of such texts is not to uncover the author but to provoke the reader (or listener) into considering their own thoughts and finding their own good mother in music.
If you enjoy what you read here, feel free to sign up for my monthly newsletter to catch up on all things learning, edtech and storytelling.Share this:EmailRedditTwitterPocketTumblrLinkedIn
Review â Enya: A Treatise on Unguilty Pleasures by Chilly Gonzales by Aaron Davis is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.